and the best drummer is....[views:21384][posts:99]__________________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 9:35am - TheGreatSpaldino ""] anonymous said:here is the continuance for anonymous, here is the list 1. Pete Sandoval 2. Derek Roddy (first shot on KOAK, try that posers) 3. Flo mournier 4. Tony Laureano/Max(Krisiun)/Jon Longstreth 5. Trym(Emperor)/Raymod Herrera(Fear Factory) 6. Dave Culross/Doc (Vader)/Steve Asheim(Deicide) 7. Frederik (marduk)/ Nick Barker/Zak(Goatwhore) 8. Alex Henandez/Craig Smilowski 9. Sean Reinert/Gene Hoglan/Richard Christy wow... you are a total moron if you think Steve Asheim is worth mentioning. besides... you are totally forgetting about Opeth's drummer... he is just as good as Roddy if not better. besides, jazz drummers and prog drummers are amazing as well. there are other things besides speed... like groove. ill take groove over speed any day... i also would love to hear you play sometime if you think you are so amazing at drums. but yes, your list is beyond flawed. |
| ______________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 12:57pm - the_rooster ""] flo kevin tally thomas haake ken shalk dave lombardo vinnie paul the dude from wormed the dude from ion dissonance goratory's new drummer nick barker brain (primus) danny carey (tool) mitch mitchell (hendrix experience) plenty of others that i can't think of right now...longstreth is overrated. |
| _____________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 1:05pm - RustedAngel ""] anonymous said:here is the continuance for anonymous, here is the list 1. Pete Sandoval 2. Derek Roddy (first shot on KOAK, try that posers) 3. Flo mournier 4. Tony Laureano/Max(Krisiun)/Jon Longstreth 5. Trym(Emperor)/Raymod Herrera(Fear Factory) 6. Dave Culross/Doc (Vader)/Steve Asheim(Deicide) 7. Frederik (marduk)/ Nick Barker/Zak(Goatwhore) 8. Alex Henandez/Craig Smilowski 9. Sean Reinert/Gene Hoglan/Richard Christy 1 hahah you fuckin reject, we named pretty much all of those drummers before you even knew about this site...gaylord. |
| _____________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 1:05pm - RustedAngel ""] RustedAngel said:Martin Lopez (opeth) Derek Roddy (hate eternal) Mike Portnoy (dream theater, osi) Flo Mournier (cryptopsy) Pete Sandoval (morbid angel) Tomas Haake (meshuggah) Morgan Agren (fredrick thordendal) Kenneth Shalk (candiria) Daniel Erlandson (arch enemy) Gene Holgan (testament, devin townsend) Jon Legstrenth (origin, who cares about skinless) Chad Walls aka CPT KILLDRUMS (brodequin, enter self) Vitek (decapitated) Janne Saarenpää (the crown) Nick Barker (cof, dimmu, old mans child) :satancross::NEWHORNS::satancross::shocked: |
| _____________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 4:32pm - Josh_Martin ""] Mitch Mitchell Eric Brecht Dave Grave Mick Harris Les Binks Ian Paice Bill Ward Dana Collins Dave Lombardo Keith Moon |
| ________________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 4:38pm - Josh_hates_you ""] the fat black guy in boston with the bucket. he rules. |
| ___________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 5:11pm - JellyFish ""] trym torson-emperor/enslaved pete sandoval-morbid angel martin lopez-opeth/amon amarth hellhammer-mayhem nick barker-dimmu borgir gene hoglan-death/strapping/testament derek roddy-hate eternal tony laureano-nile/angelcorpse kevin talley-fetus/misery index many many more |
| ___________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 5:20pm - JellyFish ""] Christraper said:Hellhammer Frost Dave Lombardo Gene Hoglan Bard Faust Pete Sandoval Gar Samuelsen how could you mention bard faust and not trym? Faust is definetly a great drummer and he got better with every album but his drummer cant hold a candle to tryms. |
| __________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 5:44pm - mike_fod ""] Tomas Haake, Flo Mournier, Morgan Ågren, Raymond Herrera, Dennis Chambers, Richard Christy, Ricky Myers, Buddy Rich, Stef Broks, John Stanier, Danny Carey....... |
| ___________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 6:06pm - Dissector ""] Chris - Autopsy King - Deceased Dennis - Macabre Dave - Repulsion Pete - during the Terrorizer days (ONE FOOT!) |
| __________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 6:11pm - mike_fod ""] Dissector said:Chris - Autopsy King - Deceased Dennis - Macabre Dave - Repulsion Pete - during the Terrorizer days (ONE FOOT!) Pete was fast, especially on World Downfall, but Dave Witte from Discordance Axis / Human Remains has him beat with single kick blasting. |
| ______________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 6:14pm - swamplorddvm ""] Not derik |
| ___________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 6:15pm - JellyFish ""] hahahahahahha |
| __________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 6:23pm - Kalopsia ""] RustedAngel said:drummer from berzerker isn't that good, he's got his drums triggered with delay effects on them. if his drums (or anyone's drums for that matter) are specially triggered or have a delay effect on them to make it sound like they're going faster than they are really playing, then how the fuck do they pull off slower parts in songs when they only hit the bass drum once in a measure or the snare once every 2 measures????????? it can't be done. they'd have to hit a switch or something every single time those parts come up and i guarentee you they'd fuck up sooner or later. triggers do not make you sound faster, they only process the beats so that they come out of the PA clearer than miking the bass drums. i have the Berzerker's live DVD and yes he's really going that fast. as a matter of fact, there's some clips in there of the singer doing drums live last year when their drummer broke his foot, and he was going even faster. |
| ________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 8:30pm - retzam ""] I'm not sure if he's been mentioned yet, so Gavin Harrison of Porcupine Tree. |
| ____________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 8:46pm - JoeDavolla ""] Mitch Harris(former Napalm Death) Current ND drummer-I forget his name Pete Sandoval Dave Lombardo Bobby(Sodom) Ventor(Kreator) Steve(Deicide) Paul(Cannibal Corpse) Any drummer for Malevolent Creation Bill Ward-when he was younger John Bonham Paul Bostaph Cant think of nemore |
| ____________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 9:25pm - anonymous ""] It looks like I stirred up a Bees nest with the drumming and that is just fucking awesome you guys rule and yes I know of all the old schooldeath metal bands because I was the drummer for one of the very first death metal bands on Relapse and have played with alot of the above mentioned and yes the guy from Human Reamains, hellhammer, and Brandon Thomas (ripping corpse) rule too laters metal eaters and keep it BRUTAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
| __________________________________________ [Jul 22,2004 11:57pm - attendmyrequiem ""] Tomas Haake - Meshuggah Flo Mourier - Cryptopsy Kevin Tally - Dying Fetus/Misery Index/Soils of Fate Trym - Emperor/Zyklon Ken Shalk - Candiria Chris Pennie - The Dillinger Escape Plan John Legstrenth - Origin Mike Justaine - The Red Chord Justin Foley - Blood has been Shed |
| _________________________________ [Jul 23,2004 12:05am - retzam ""] Hmmm... one of the first dm bands on Relapse. I'm intrigued. |
| ___________________________________ [Jul 23,2004 12:10am - powerkok ""] blah blah blah Ringo starr blah blah blah and the guy from inxs was awesome. eat me. |
| __________________________________ [Jul 23,2004 8:28am - heimdall ""] best metal drummers are the dude from blind guardian and the guy form lost horizon the guy from beserker is just gay know one likes boring beats even if they are the fastest in the world |
| ______________________________________ [Jul 25,2004 11:28pm - 3rd_Knuckle ""] Animal from the Muppet Show Band rocked |
| _______________________________________ [Aug 28,2004 3:18am - Warren Peace ""] I never heard one mention of the drummer from Hella[img] Zach Hill |
| _____________________________________ [Aug 28,2004 11:46am - El Justin ""] I don't play drums, so I don't know what determines the "best". . . so I'm just gonna list my favorite drummers to watch/listen to that always amaze me Dave Witte (BBTS, Discordance Axis, Human Remains, EWBT, billion others) John Longstrenth (Origin, Skinless, Angelcorpse, Red Chord, etc) Flo Mounier (Cryptopsy, I hear he's Cory Hart's live drummer as well) Darren don't know last name(Goratory, Pillory... the guy is ridiculous) Steve McDonald (Gorguts) Derek Roddy (Hate Eternal) Dusty Clapham (Clitorture) Andy don't know last name (Wormed) |
| ____________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 4:45pm - anonymous ""] clive burr nicko mcbrain mikkey dee dave lombardo pete sandoval these are a few drummers that really made an impact |
| _____________________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 5:08pm - This_Is_Heresy nli ""] Becuase I dont think he was mentioned yet... Inferno from Behemoth |
| _________________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 5:31pm - DreamingInExile ""] What about Van Williams of Nevermore? and maybe Anthony "I look like I'm 12" Simone of Coffin Birth? give him a couple of years more and he'll be up there amongst the best. |
| ____________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 10:17pm - contagion ""] darren cesca is better than everyone. |
| ______________________________________________________________________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 10:45pm - Tsectpathogen (Anthony "I look like im 12" simone of coffin birth) ""] In no particular order Bobby Jarzombek (spastic ink, halford various other notable projects) Dennis Chambers Tony Williams Darren Cesca Derrek Roddy Steve Gadd TERRY BOZZIO BUDDY FUCKING RICH Thomas Haake I dont really see whats so special about the red chords drummer really *shrugs* |
| ___________________________________ [Feb 17,2006 10:48pm - Aegathis ""] DreamingInExile said:What about Van Williams of Nevermore? and maybe Anthony "I look like I'm 12" Simone of Coffin Birth? give him a couple of years more and he'll be up there amongst the best. Give him a few years and he will look older than 12!!! |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:03am - dwellingsickness ""] Nick from Life at Zero:NEWHORNS: |
| ________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:08am - MetalcoreSUCKS ""] Paul Bostaph-Exodus Pete Sandoval-Morbid Angel/Terrorizer Dave Lombardo-Slayer Bobby-Sodom Paul Masurkewitz-Cannibal Corpse |
| ________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:09am - MetalcoreSUCKS ""] Forgot to mention Mike Justian from Candy Striper Death Ordy/Unearth |
| ________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:11am - MetalcoreSUCKS ""] Current Napalm Death drummer(forgot his name) Ventor-Kreator Vinny Apice John Bonham Bill Ward Nick Barker-Lock up Boring drummers: Any of the ones who played with AC/DC |
| ________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:12am - MetalcoreSUCKS ""] MetalcoreSUCKS said:Forgot to mention Mike Justian from Candy Striper Death Ordy/Unearth *Orgy |
| ______________________________ [Feb 18,2006 8:25am - wade ""] HORGH! |
| _________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 9:04am - DreamingInExile ""] dwellingsickness said:Nick from Life at Zero:NEWHORNS: SHIT YES!!!!! I forgot him, that's it, I'm fired... |
| _________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 9:05am - DreamingInExile ""] and another one we've forgotten: Virgil Donati - Planet X |
| ________________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 10:38am - babaganoosh3 ""] Just about all the great metal drummers have been listed as far as I saw, except I didn't see Jason Rullo from Symphony X who is an unbelievably tight drummer with incredible feel. However, no one mentioned MARCO MINNEMAN? Have you seen that fucker drum? It hurts just to watch... |
| _______________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 10:55am - Anthony nli ""] the dude from Arsis is incredible. |
| _______________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 12:53pm - the rooster ""] Anthony nli said:the dude from Arsis is incredible. i second that. dude is fucking nasty. i personally think longstreth is highly overrated. my list (metal and non): thomas haake - meshuggah dave witte - bbts mike smith - suffocation john - cephalic carnage lee - commit suicide kevin talley - misery index / fetus igor cavalera - sepultura jimmie kyle - acid bath jimmy bower - crowbar tim alexander - primus jason roeder - neurosis bonham - zeppelin mitch mitchell - jimi hendrix experience danny carey - tool sean kinney - alice in chains abe cunningham - deftones |
| ___________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 3:22pm - DJ Death ""] 1) Jan Axl Hellhammer Blomberg (Mayhem/Arcturus) 2) Xytras (Samael) 3) Pete Sandoval (Morbid Angel) 4) Nicklas Rudolfsson (Sacramentum) 5) Ole Ohman (Dissection, The Black) 6) Terry Bozzio- Melodic Drummer |
| ____________________________________ [Feb 18,2006 3:23pm - RichHorror ""] Does it matter who's the best? Whoever it is, he's just going to quit and his band's going to spend the next three years begging for a new one on the internet anyway. |
| ______________________________ [Feb 20,2006 1:04pm - Yeti ""] Dave fucking Suzuki Nick Barker Hellhammer the dude from Pillory Ian Cote Casey of Suicide Dream Tomas Haake Martin Lopez Steve Asheim Trym Chris Adler Danny Carey |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 20,2006 1:12pm - brendanrage ""] uhh didn't mike justian quit the red chord like 2 years ago for unearth? |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 21,2006 6:17pm - BlackoutRick ""] brendanrage said:uhh didn't mike justian quit the red chord like 2 years ago for unearth? Yup. I can't believe no one mentioned Billy Cobham or John Stanier. I agree with all the above posts with Gene Hoglan, John from Cephalic, Dave Witte,etc.. How about Dave McClain? |
| ________________________________ [Feb 21,2006 6:47pm - retzam ""] John Bonham Flo Mournier Hellhammer Pete Sandoval Martin Lopez Bill Ward Nick Mason |
| __________________________________ [Feb 21,2006 8:45pm - metalguy ""] I am absolutely mortified that only one person mention Chris Pennie. He is probably.. The best drummer in all of extreme metal hands down. There are tons of drummer worthy of mention but he is probably the only guy that actually sticks out. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 21,2006 8:47pm - metalguy ""] O... This is drummer... overall..... woops... HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!! Dave Weckl or Elvin Jones! But seriously! Since Dave is still alive I think he wins this one. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 21,2006 8:52pm - metalguy ""] . |