Judas Priest ripping off Janes Addiction?[views:2740][posts:38]______________________________ [Feb 18,2005 2:22pm - nate ""] anyone heard the song "Retribution" from JP? I think that's the song name... anyway the main riff is almost identical to "Mountain Song" by Janes Addiction! |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 2:22pm - the_reverend ""] yeah, isn't this old news? |
| ______________________________ [Feb 18,2005 2:24pm - nate ""] maybe it is, but I just heard the JP song for the first time at the radio hear at work... I never listen to the radio elsewhere so I hadn't heard... so go poop in your own pants or something! |
| __________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 3:01pm - litacore ""] yeah but Jane's Addiction are gayer than Rob Halford AND Dave Holland put together besides, J.A. ripped off Zeppelin shamelessly |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 3:34pm - shatteredliz ""] The song is called Revolution--the CD is Angel of Retribution. If you were wondering. |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:06pm - Hooker ""] Note for note ripoff. And welcome to a month ago. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:19pm - Phil E. ""] who gives a shit, listen to the whole album its good. |
| ______________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:24pm - blue ""] its good, but not great. |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:26pm - Hooker ""] It's gonna suck when this pales next to Painkiller. I'm going to be disappointed. |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:34pm - shatteredliz ""] Let's just enjoy it for what it is, not compare it to the past... |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:35pm - Hooker ""] I'm going to buy it. But it's going to disappoint me. |
| ______________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:39pm - blue ""] shatteredliz said:Let's just enjoy it for what it is, not compare it to the past... cmon liz, how can you not compare this cd to painkiller? i find this cd to resemble more of the 'rocka rolla' era priest. |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:41pm - shatteredliz ""] Yeah, I agree... |
| _____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:52pm - Josh_Martin ""] Hooker said:It's gonna suck when this pales next to Painkiller. I'm going to be disappointed. Painkiller is totally overrated. Their 70's stuff kills it. Stained Class owns everything. |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:53pm - Hooker ""] Overrated? Not really. Most people go with British Steel or Screaming as their handjob worthy albums. |
| _____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:55pm - Josh_Martin ""] Sad Wings, Sin After Sin, and Stained Class is the trifecta. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 4:58pm - Phil E. ""] Josh Martin is correct. Nothing tops Stained Class, Saints in Hell, Exciter, Heros End,Savage(sounds like a Deep Purple song but better)....come on! Sin after Sin is better then all the 80's albums combined too, not to say i dont like those or even painkiller |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:00pm - Hooker ""] Yeah, it's kind of apples, oranges... and... some other fruit... Halfords or something. You got 70's rock and roll priest, 80's buttsex metal priest and then Painkiller. An album that I include in my top 5 best modern metal albums of all time. They all sound so different. |
| _____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:01pm - Josh_Martin ""] Last time I saw Priest (w/ Ripper) the only reason I went was because I heard they were going to play Exciter. They did. It ruled. |
| _____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:02pm - Josh_Martin ""] Stained Class is the blueprint for all modern metal. |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:05pm - Hooker ""] I have everything except stained class. I have to get that shit. Painkiller is the blueprint for power metal. Which, most of the time isn't a good thing. But still. I love that album. blah blah blah. |
| _____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:07pm - Josh_Martin ""] I thought Manowar was the blueprint for power metal. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:08pm - Phil E. ""] apples, oranges or whatever....70's preist cant be topped. As for the 80's British Steel>defenders of the faith>Screaming for vengence |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:11pm - Hooker ""] manowar is the blueprint for all that is wrong in this world. |
| _________________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:15pm - DreamingInExile ""] Hooker said:manowar is the blueprint for all that is wrong in this world. no, I think that award goes to Marlyn Manson and ICP |
| __________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:17pm - Phil E. ""] Manowar on battle hymns wasnt powermetal....that album is just great. |
| ________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:36pm - Hooker ""] I love Manowar, but they're the worst band in the world. |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:56pm - BestialOnslaught ""] HELLOWEEN's MLP and Walls Of Jericho are the blueprint for Power Metal. Painkiller in the grand scheme of things is only better than Jugulator, the crappy one after it, Ram It Down and Turbo... I definitely think it's overrated to some degree, though I do like it. Unleashed In The East is the tops (and it's no surprise since it has 4 Sad Wings songs). |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:57pm - BestialOnslaught ""] MANOWAR is Heavy Metal, and damn good at it. |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 5:57pm - BestialOnslaught ""] Hooker said:manowar is the blueprint for all that is wrong in this world. Then why do you cover them? |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 6:39pm - chris black ""] Painkiller blows. Anyway, the Janes/Judas thing has been on my mind for years, the whole flamboyant squeaky frontman thing. The verses of "Mountain Song" are structured just like "Victim of Changes" anyway, so it really is old news. Also, the definition of power metal changed significantly since its introduction in the 80s. |
| ______________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 7:14pm - th3rdknuckle ""] Sad Wings of Destiny was Priests 'blueprint' album. There they invented modern Heavy Metal (as opposed to the primarily blues-based stuff that existed before it). |
| ____________________________________ [Feb 18,2005 7:54pm - El Justin ""] jane's addiction are one of the best bands ever |
| ___________________________________________ [Feb 21,2005 12:51pm - BestialOnslaught ""] chris black said:The verses of "Mountain Song" are structured just like "Victim of Changes" anyway, so it really is old news. I brought this up last time this thread was done a month or two ago, but noone seemed to take notice. |
| _________________________________ [Feb 21,2005 12:57pm - Hooker ""] It's the riff that bothers me. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 21,2005 1:01pm - Phil E. ""] the more i listen to the single the more i like it. Overall i like the new album.....as good as anything motorhead and Maiden have done in the last few years. |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 21,2005 1:45pm - BestialOnslaught ""] Hooker said:It's the riff that bothers me. I'll be sure to let Glenn and KK know, they'll be devastated. |
| __________________________________ [Feb 21,2005 2:23pm - litacore ""] you I never heard 'Painkiller', just the song itself and the Death cover (of course) I'd written them off after Turbo (I was 18 at the time, and its weakness pissed me off), perhaps prematurely perhaps I should check 'Painkiller' out, as a whole Stained Class = LOOK MA, NO FACE! (James Vance) |
| __________________________________________ [Feb 22,2005 5:04am - BestialOnslaught ""] litacore said:Stained Class = LOOK MA, NO FACE! (James Vance) Baaaahahaha.... Better By James Vance, Better Than Raymond Belknap! |